Celebration constipation.

Yay progress!

I read newsfeeds daily from aggregators Google news, Apple news, and Flipboard, and try to mix what the aggregators call “conservative view” and “liberal view”. Sometimes I just rapidly flip through the Flipboard feed, looking for headlines that appear interesting. Today something suddenly hit me, so I went back and checked my perception. I look at the headlines, and try to guess the media outlet pushing them. While the following list is certainly not definitive, it is representative. The following outlets are almost entirely leaning in one direction on what they report and especially how they report it.

“Conservative view” (“Right-leaning “) outlets include Fox News, Daily Signal, Redstate, Townhall, the Resurgent, The Blaze, Dailywire, New York Post, thefederalist.com, newsbusters.org. Some of the more in-depth and analytical publications/websites include National Review and Imprimis, a publication of Hillsdale College. I can’t think of any “entertainment” and sports related outlets that discuss or promote conservative thought or ideas. In radio is where conservative ideas have a huge following: Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity, Dennis Prager, Glenn Beck.

“Liberal view” (“Left-leaning”) outlets include Slate, Vox, CNN, MSNBC, Washington Post, VICE, Quartz, New York Times, DailyKos, LA Times. In-depth publications include The Atlantic, The New Yorker, New York magazine. “Entertainment” and Sports publications/websites include ESPN, Rolling Stone, Mother Jones. Since I never listen to the radio anymore, I don’t know who’s big in the liberal radio space.

There’s enough outlets to promote any point of view, but of all the conservative view outlets, only one has a TV network, Fox. The liberal view has three TV networks, NBC, ABC and CBS, and three of the major newspapers in the country. There’s no question that the left-leaning outlets as a group have the money, infrastructure and technology to reach multiple more people than right-leaning as a group, though Fox is competitive with the liberal TV outlets. Radio is much more egalitarian. It doesn’t take a cable TV subscription to listen, getting a radio show is less expensive and rigorous than a TV show, and there are far more radio stations than TV networks and their affiliates. Forbes had an article focusing on why conservative radio so dramatically outpaces liberal or progressive radio, and even the writer’s obvious prejudice against conservative radio could not adequately explain, though there was lots of speculation. The one reason is the one they left out. Love is stronger than hate, celebration is better than denigration.

Both conservatives and progressives spend more of their time and verbiage criticizing each other than complimenting each other, but mark the differences in criticism: most conservative criticism of progressives is about their policies rather than attacks on them personally, though Rush in particular offers many humorous aphorisms and nicknames, thinking of himself as an entertainer more than commentator; progressives often attack conservatives personally, and their minions’ behavior is emblematic, like MAGA hat harassment. Conservatives generally criticize progressive policies because they love our country and want to protect it against bad policies; progressives demonstrate repeatedly contempt for our history, traditions and freedoms, especially the most basic freedoms of speech and life. I believe that many, if not most, progressives actually hate our country. Perhaps the most important distinction is between celebration and denigration.

I spend hours reading headlines and articles from both points of view, and I am struck, or as I said in my third sentence it hit me, how little, closer to nonexistent, is celebration of anything or anyone in progressive/liberal/left media. Personal attacks abound. “Trump screws this up, Trump lies, Trump is guilty, the Rich suck, the U.S. sucks….and on” dominate their headlines. I went back over days worth of headlines and couldn’t find a single one celebrating anything except imagined defeats for Trump or doxing some helpless senior for MAGA hatcrime. While many conservative/right headlines were also negative about opponents, there were many that celebrated achievements of individuals, regardless of skin color or nationality or ethnicity. Speaking for myself, I love to follow stories of achievements, in sports and otherwise. Rising above adversity, after a long period of wounding, even self-inflicted, is inspiring. Tiger Woods winning the Masters, years after he crashed and burned, battling back after injuries and an avalanche of negative publicity, was riveting for me, even though I have no interest in golf or Tiger personally. I never even liked him. But this is different.

Celebration of achievement creates a brotherhood/sisterhood of sorts. It unifies. Criticism divides, the even when it leads to improving what was criticized. I believe the essential difference between most conservative and most liberal media is the pleasure they get from celebrating vs. criticizing, respectively. Even what is perceived by the other side as negative, differs in tone. Here’s a typical headline from Thefederalist.com: “School climate survey” tells students “gender is how a person feels.” It’s straight reporting, but the facts are damning of liberals to conservatives. Here’s a typical headline, on the same page of my Flipboard feed, from Rolling Stone: “Notre Dame burning feels like an act of liberation.” The most critical conservative headline I could find today was from theamericanconservative.com: “Do Democrats even care about the Purple States?” But the actual article itself was factual reporting rather than mere opinions. 

With the last 3 years of daily news feed reading, I can’t recall a single headline from the progressive/liberal/left media space celebrating any individual achievement. There was lots of celebrations: more laws liberalizing abortion, more investigations of Trump, more harassment of MAGA hats, more lawsuits restricting individual  freedoms, but nothing that was good for this country. There’s no laxative for celebration constipation.   


Author: iamcurmudgeon

When I began this blog, I was a 70 year old man, with a young mind and a body trying to recover from a stroke, and my purpose for this whole blog thing is to provoke thinking, to ridicule reflex reaction, and provide a legacy to my children.

2 thoughts on “Celebration constipation.”

  1. Loved it. So true, although I have never heard Tiger repent for anything he did to shipwreck himself. He may have, and I didn’t read it. Somehow I can’t be too excited about him.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s