Forced restitution, do we have the courage?

A 47-year-old man charged last week with a violent attempt to kidnap a 9-year-old girl and break into a South Seattle apartment has been arrested 104 previous times in King County over the last 14 years, according to court records. Seattle police arrested Randolph Neil Humiston on May 30 at 14th Avenue South and South Henderson Street after he allegedly grabbed and dragged a girl on a playground, according to charging documents. Prosecutors say the girl kicked and screamed at Humiston until he released her. Court records indicate many times, Humiston was released within a day or two after being arrested, and he consistently listed his address as the Compass Housing Alliance in Seattle, indicating he is homeless. Prosecutors noted Humiston was placed in the jail’s psych ward in 2017, and would “likely commit an act of violence,” if released. Records indicate a few of the cases were dismissed because Humiston was found to be incompetent. Humiston’s career criminal conviction resume includes four felonies, and 38 gross misdemeanors including “Threats to Kill, Assault, Resisting Arrest, Stalking, Escape, Indecent Exposure, Possession of a Dangerous Weapon and many Vehicle Prowl” and multiple drug convictions, according to court records.

I don’t know what goes through your mind when you read an item like that. Here’s what I think: I don’t care if he’s legally “competent” or not. He’s a violent, dangerous career criminal who does not deserve to suck up social and law enforcement resources. Keeping him in prison is just another way of wasting tax dollars on a worthless hunk of protoplasm. The Bible uses the word worthless over 50 times to describe “worthless fellows” who lie, rob, injure and kill, so don’t tell me I can’t be Christian if I use that word. A Christian doesn’t have to try to be “nicer than Jesus.” Jesus kicked plenty of butt, when appropriate.

If it were up to me, I would institute a form of forced restitution for the career offender, or even the criminally insane, to make them start paying back to society for what their behavior has cost. This assumes that they have not yet been convicted of a prosecutable crime. If they have been, the law already prescribes penalties. Someone like Humiston may be incompetent to stand trial (really? but competent enough to escape the consequences of his acts?) but he can do manual labor. After a certain number of arrests, or a certain amount of civic costs and have been accrued, a person like him should be given a choice: forced labor in a controlled environment (so he can’t escape or injure innocents while serving his restitution), the amount and nature to be determined by a judge, or exile to a penal camp in a remote location, like many countries used to have. The penal camp would still put him to work, but in much more unpleasant conditions.

Objections: How many offenses or arrests would be required? Who decides? Isn’t it a cruel and inhumane idea? What about the offender’s rights? Answering in reverse order: What about the victims’ rights, and the taxpayers’ rights? Cruel and inhumane compared to whatuselessly sitting in prison or a nuthouse is even more cruel, at least with my idea, he’d have a chance at the dignity of paying back. Who makes the laws? Who prosecutes criminals? Who metes out punishment? The mechanism could be the same. How many arrests would trigger the restitution? Does it really matter? Anything is better than allowing someone like Humiston inflict himself on the victims.

I don’t think we have the courage as a society to implement my idea.

Author: iamcurmudgeon

When I began this blog, I was a 70 year old man, with a young mind and a body trying to recover from a stroke, and my purpose for this whole blog thing is to provoke thinking, to ridicule reflex reaction, and provide a legacy to my children.

2 thoughts on “Forced restitution, do we have the courage?”

  1. No, we don’t. Much too logical, practical and biblical. Called indentured servitude in the Bible. But what would God know about it?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s